Shipping Details
    Terms & Conditions
  • $99 minimum order required, excluding gift cards
  • Enter promotion code 4XFREE during checkout
  • Additional shipping charges for large or heavy items still apply
  • Good on Standard Express shipping to U.S. Deliverable Addresses ONLY
  • Offer expires 10/21/14, 11:59 p.m. (EDT)
  • Not valid with any other offer
  • Offer cannot be used on prior purchases
  • Offer is valid for purchases made at or catalog call center
  • Cabela's reserves the right to exclude certain products from this promotion
  • Not available to Cabela's employees
Dealing with Henned-up Gobblers at Cabela's

Dealing with Henned-up Gobblers

Author: M.D. Johnson

Modify your hunting strategy this season for more birds regardless of the conditions.

Sometimes ambushing toms with the use of a blind is the way to go.

Many years ago, Mother Nature decided that turkeys were going to work this way - "The tom will gobble, and the hen will go to him." That's the way it started, and that's the way it's been for centuries.

Enter Man. Humans, being the intelligent individuals that we are, decided we would do just the opposite. Basically, we humans said - "No, Mother Nature. It's not going to work that way. We're going to call like the hen, and the gobbler is going to trip over himself to come see us." And so it was done.

As many turkey hunters know, sometimes this role-reversal works. We call, and the tom actually does fall over himself. Often, however, this clever ploy fails. And at no time is this charade more likely to fail than when the gobbler in question has all the female company he can handle. In the turkey hunter's vernacular, such a bird is said to be 'henned-up'. To some, however, this situation is known simply as impossible.

But are these henned-up gobblers really impossible? According to some veterans of the spring woods, there are gobblers that no one, regardless of their experience, will ever coax into shotgun range. Such woods-wraiths are the exception, though, as henned-up toms can be had - the difference being that these toms with company require an even bigger dose of patience, persistence, and self-discipline that does a lonely longbeard. Oh, and a basket full of tricks doesn't hurt either.

Done correctly, mature toms can be called away from the hens.

Find Another Bird
Sounds good, eh...but unfortunately, this one's often much more easier said than done. Yes, I have found myself in situations where I could turn 'round and stop in any of 360 degree compass directions and be facing a hard-gobbling bird. Has it happened? Yes. A lot? No.

That said, I'll put it this way. If you have the choice between a henned-up tom and a gobbling, but as yet unseen bird, maybe the best move is just that - move. Or if you know that there are plenty of turkeys on the ground you're hunting and you have plenty of ground to hunt, there again the best decision might be to leave the henned-up gobbler alone for the time being and try your luck elsewhere; however, if you're like most of us - myself very much included here - who has a finite amount of ground and a limited number of opportunities, you're going to have to try something else. But don't fret just yet. Read on.

Hunt 10 to 2
So you left that first light, henned-up longbeard alone and ventured off in the opposite direction hoping to cross paths with a bird that didn't have so much company? Well, if you weren't successful in locating another more willing bird, perhaps the best chance you have is to go back to the original gobbler and pick up where you left off. Hopefully, the hens that were with him at first light are now tending to some housekeeping or clutch-building chores. The gobbler, on the other hand, has been alone for five minutes, and in gobbler time....well, that's a heck of a long time.

Go back to the same spot where you worked him off the roost, but be careful. He may already be there waiting on that 'hen' he heard squawking at daybreak. I don't know how many times I've walked away from an impossible, henned-up situation, only to return three or four hours later to find a very amorous longbeard standing in the indentation my backside had made earlier that morning. Take your time as you move back into position. Use a crow call or an owl hooter instead of a turkey call as a way of probing what's now his perimeter. The biggest key here is not to rush. He has all the time in the world; so should you.

By modifying your tactics this season, you can overcome the Henned Up gobbler problem.

Pattern Your Gobbler
Okay, so I'm a slow learner. During the 2002 spring season in Iowa, I had not one or two, but four big gobblers, all of whom frustrated me day after day after day. Only after the season ended did it strike me that these same toms that were frazzling my nerves also were in the same place at near the same time day after day after day. Can you say ground blind and a good book? That's all it would have taken; that, and a little patience. Still, I eventually did learn, and these bad boys will have a surprise waiting on them come late April this year.

The moral of the story is this - patterning turkeys can and does work; that is, IF you pay attention and learn what the birds have to teach you. In these instances, I was dealing with a single gobbler with his four or so hens, and a trio of longbeards, typically strutting around one or two girls. Same point and knob, every day. Here, the ticket would have been simply to set up a blind within shotgun range of the boys' dance floor, get in well before daylight, and be ready when he - or they - stepped out. No calling, you say? That's all right. It's important that you remember you don't have to get $20 out of your $20 box call each and every time you step into the field. My theory is simple - If I can pattern him and kill him without calling, I'm okay with that. I can always call on my way home.

Bust the Roost
Eastern Iowa, and the sun's just barely beginning to make an appearance. Julie, my wife, and I are 'guiding' her eldest son, Adrian, on one of his first turkey hunts. At the fence that separates the pasture from the small timber, we stop. Suddenly below us, a bird gobbles. "This is a good thing," I tell the boy, already on my way over the fence. Adrian and his Mom follow suit; however, before we go 12 feet, a hen erupts out of one of the maples above us. My thoughts are cut short as the bird below us gobbles. Then another hen flushes, cackling. More gobbling. Another hen. More gobbles. Another. Gobble. In all, eight or 10 hens flush into the darkness, each departure met with a burst of gobbling. "This is either real good," I tell my partners. "Or real bad."

A long story short, it was REAL good. Now tremendously alone, the old bird hit the ground and wasted no time walking up to our position. The boy, after multitudinous contortions and the Seven Basic Gymnastic Movements, finally got turned around and killed the big old three-year-old at about 18 steps. It was, as everyone agreed, very - very - cool.

Honestly, I believe the only reason we were successful that morning was the fact that we had inadvertently chased all that old gobbler's hens away. Elemental? Yep, but it did teach me something. When all else fails, separating a tom from his hens, either at night or in the morning and under cover of darkness, can be an effective way of dealing with an always henned-up bird.

Using multiple decoys will help improve your odds this spring.
Use decoys aggressively, and by aggressively, I'm speaking in terms of a couple different schools of thought. One, go to multiple decoy set-ups; that is, half a dozen hens, a couple jakes, and a half-strut gobbler. Find yourself a place in the middle of daily turkey traffic - stake out your fakes, pull up a comfortable seat, and wait.

Often, I'll do very little calling while using such multiple decoy spreads, relying instead on the visual rather than the aural attraction; however, should the individual bird warrant such tactics and the location be suitably safe, I will throw out an enthusiastic gobble every now and then, particularly if I can see the bird and note his reaction. Or lack thereof. Remember, there's nothing wrong with experimentation. A second aggressive set-up consists of gobbler-only decoys. Here, I'm referring to half-strut or even full-strut gobblers and fake jakes. It's a dominance thing, and sometimes it works. Sometimes, it doesn't.

Calling the Girls
Finally, there's that old chestnut - call the hens. Well, you can try that, but like the use of decoys, there are a couple theories here. One, you can call non-aggressively. The thought here is that the hens with the gobbler will eventually wander off to see what this outsider is clucking and purring and yelping about. The hens come, the gobbler obediently follows, and you shoot him. Sometimes, it's best to sound like several contented non-aggressive turkeys. Think like people, people. Isn't a dozen-unseen voices much more intriguing than what sounds like but one person talking? Secondly, you can be aggressive with your calling; however, this can go one of two ways. Either the dominant hen will be offended and will approach your position, ready to give this invisible interloper a whipping. Or she'll be intimidated, and she'll walk away from the ruckus - and, yes, leading your gobbler by the snood. It's really your call - no pun intended! - Always remember when dealing with henned-up toms...what do you have to lose? He wasn't coming anyway.

Click this link to purchase a turkey call.

— Your complete source for more Cabela's News, and updated hunting and fishing articles.