Top Rated Product

Customer Product Reviews

1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

All the legendary accuracy and dependability of the classic New Army .44 Caliber is now available in this more compact model. The 5-1/2" barrel makes it easier to holster and handle. Overall length: 11-1/2". Weight: 2 lbs. 9 oz.

Average Customer Rating:

4.6 out of 5

46 of 46 (100%) customers would recommend this product to a friend.

Customer Reviews for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

5 out of 5

1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver, October 12, 2009
By DCB1903 from Eaton Rapids, MI

"I have a 1858 New Army 8" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver.
But with that barrel size I pull up too much. But right out of the box I was hitting the bull, or in a good zone to stop what ever I shoot at. I am still working with the 8" so one day I will be hitting the bull with the 8" too."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 2 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

3 out of 5

Loved it but..., September 17, 2009
By OlePa57 from Farmington, Utah

"Cabelas: ***** for customer service.
Workmanship: ** The first pistol that I bought had the 8” barrel (same basic pistol with longer loading lever and barrel). It was soon delivering 2” groups at 25 yards, however occasionally the hammer became stuck and I had to remove and replace the cylinder in order to resume operation. I exchanged the 8" model with Cabelas for this model (5 1/2” barrel, more $$). I found that it was difficult to latch the hammer, but did not want to return to Cabelas, so I fixed it by deburring the trigger and hammer, improving the trigger pull. Burrs on the plunger caused it to hang up in the cylinder, which I also fixed. The first time that I pulled the trigger, the loading lever unlatched and fell down, and continued to do so with every shot, so I rested it on a bag, and was soon shooting 2” groups(despite shorter barrel). I filed and fit to achieve positive latching of the loading lever, then cold blued my de-burr jobs.
Fun: ***** If you have the patience to work through the manufacturing defects (I do) you may love this thing! I have a number of modern semi-automatic pistols, but this is the funnest thing that I own. Both pistols delivered excellent groups, and I can shoot for hours on very little $$ (because it takes so long to load). I am now looking at either an 1860 or an 1851."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 3 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

4 out of 5

1858 NMA 5.5" .44 cal pistol, June 30, 2009
By Ginormous from Atlanta, GA

"Ordered 2 of these, one for me, and one for my daughter, who's developed an interest in BP pistol shooting. Both pistols arrived VERY quickly, well packed, and looked flawless. The Pietta style grips are larger than Uberti's grips on the same model, which users with large hands will definitely appreciate. No more finger bruising when you shoot this pistol, since there's plenty of room for your fingers behind the trigger guard!

Hammer and trigger action was good out of the box, although the triggers do show a bit of creep, before releasing smartly. A little work with polishing stones will clean that up for me in no time. Overall fit and finish on both pistols is excellent, with a very deep dark bluing on the barrel, cylinder, and frame. Nice and even - it cleans up beautifully!

The shorter barrel length definitely makes this a much more holsterable pistol, as compared to the Army length 8" models. Handles and feels a bit like a Peacemaker, although it is a bit heavier in the fore end than the Peacemaker.

All in all, a GREAT cap and ball .44 pistol for the money!"

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 4 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

4 out of 5

one flaw, June 26, 2009
By Orygunner

"An astounding value, with one flaw that keeps it out of the "too good to be true" catagory. The flaw is the trigger. It is way too stiff and lacks feel. I have noticed a dramatic improvement after 50 or so rounds fired. However it remains the weak link in an otherwise excellent product. I know a gunsmith who told me to put about 100 rounds through it as is, then bring it to him if i'm still not satisfied. He said it was an easy job but should be done after it has been broken in properly. All in all I'm very satisfied."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 5 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

4 out of 5

Surprising, June 24, 2009
By BPMS from TX

"I am on my second one - the barrel catch on the first disappeared on my 15th shot. Other than that, no problems. It shoots surprisingly well (not a tack driver, but consider what you are shooting with), with 6" groups at 25' Everything fits tight, and the action is smooth. Shooting 30 grains of Pyrodex behind Hornady .451 balls."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 6 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

4 out of 5

So much fun!, June 20, 2009
By NNShooter from Newport News, VA

"Great looking gun, loads of fun to shoot, the only complaint that I have is that the shorter loading lever makes it a lot harder than the 7.5 inch barrels to load. I have two fresh gouges on my fingers from loading it, but it was totally worth it! Used 25 Grains of Pyrodex P Powder with Hornady .454 inch round balls. Low recoil, and plenty accurate from my brief test shoot."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 7 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

5 out of 5

1858 New Army 5-1/2 barrel with extra cylinder, June 15, 2009
By MRFranks from Northern California

"When I opened the box, I was greeted with the usual Italian maker's four quarts of SAE30W motor oil covering the gun, and after some de-greasing, I began the serious once-over. The gun was well fitted, all parts presented no seriously sharp edges. The grips were a little over-sized for the frame, but with a little sand paper I'll get them down to the proper size. The cylinder pin was a bit stiff, but a little dab from an old tube of graphite grease, and it moved much more smoothly. The action is slick and tight, and both cylinders interchanged with just a little work. Some light stoning of the hand, and all works quite smoothly now. Since most Italian reproduction percussion handguns have inconsistently machined nipple sizes, I swapped out the nipples on both cylinders with some American made aftermarket bronze nipples that are a snug fit for CCI #11 caps. I haven't shot the revolver yet, but if it is like my other Pietta 1858 with 8 inch barrel, it should be quite accurate. I noticed the front sight on the new gun to be a bit taller than what I've seen on other "Remmies", so I suspect it should shoot to point of aim at 25 yards with the right load."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 8 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

5 out of 5

1858 5.6 .44 revolver, June 15, 2009
By jimthegrey

"Very nice product. Smooth action, and tight frame. Shoots well. I would recommend this pistol to collectors and BP enthusiasts."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 9 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

5 out of 5

1858 new army 44 5 1/2", May 26, 2009
By capandballshooter from Alabama

"Just recieved my new 1858 pietta today. Inspected it wiped it down checked operation and headed to the range. I have been shooting black powder for over 30 yrs. Both long guns, single shot big bore pistols and revolver pistols. I still have a 1973 hewes (no longer in bussiness)1858 36 cal. That was built by pietta and still shooting it, BUT I CAN TELL YOU THAT THIS NEW PISTOLA IS THE BEST I HAVE SEEN. Out of the box the action, finish, and overall quality of workmanship is unserpassed by any I have been looking at. At the range is where you find the proof of the pudding. I loaded it up with 30grains of 3fg and .454 round ball purchased at Cabelas with a 44-45 lubed wad squezzed off the first shot at a target 30' away and caught the edge of a 1 1/2 inch bullseye only to follow up with a group with all holes touching but one and that one I was thinking how good this piece is and not concentrating on my target. I did a cylinder of draw and shoot and again it worked without missfires. I did use # 10 caps that I always press on with a wood cloths pin.out of 24 rounds I only had 1 cap come off. If you are looking for a good shooter this is the one. I am ordering the 8" model tomorrow and I am sure it will be just as good as this one. Thank you Cabelas as alway's you did it again."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 10 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

5 out of 5

One great pistol!, May 5, 2009
By Anonymous from Salisbury, NC

"Having purchased several cap and ball pistols over the years(starting in 1976 while a senior in high school, an 1860 army .44 cal. What a thrill it was, and still is, to buy a real pistol thru the mail.) I have found varying degrees of quality. Most are Pieta and co. and were good overall with a timing problem here and some looseness there, I must say this latest addition is by far the tightest, most well made black powder pistol I have ever purchased. I wouldn't hesitate to buy the smokeless powder conversion cylinder for this pistol and may in fact do so after seeing its high quality. Thanks and I'll be back for more to add to my growing collection!"

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 11 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

5 out of 5

My 1st Black Powder Experience is Awesome, May 4, 2009
By Lucky6Gun

"I bought this one after much, much thought. Loading the cylinder is much easier on this replica than the Colt Navy or Army models. I used Goex replica powder sticks (I cut them in half to fit in the cylinder) the one meant for .45 caliber and followed the wad and ball course of things. I used CCI No 10 caps. And wow! I had tons of fun shooting. Lots of smoke and inaccuracies on my part, but after much practice I was able to shoot reasonable groups.

I have an 8 inch version of this 1858, but I enjoy this shorter version much more since it is whole lot easier to aim."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 12 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

5 out of 5

best of the best, April 21, 2009
By Simbaah from Radcliff Ky.

"Very well built, remington brand is the best, and Cabelas still has great service every time, I got a conversion cylinder for this to fire 45 cowboy bullets, its awesome, I can load this remington with the conversion cylinder faster than I can load my 38 special, its just like poppin in a clip, you put all 6 bullets in at once and close the lever. I love the shorter barrel, its a nice (medium frame revolver) Medium frames are my favorite becuase the barrel is long enough to be accurate and obsorb the recoil but short enough not to be top heavy and is more manuverable. I would recomend this gun for anyone who likes to shoot or even for self defence if you get the conversion cylinder becuase you can load this thing faster than modern day revolvers but it has that classic look as well, this gun is actually the exact same model that Clint East Wood was packing in (Pale Ryder) But anyways, I already had the 36 long barrel but I must say this one is much better. P.S. remington is the best brand for doing a conversion for that fact that they can be loaded and unloaded so quickly, I still like Colts for shooting black powder and lead balls though."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 13 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

5 out of 5

1858 New Army 51/2", March 22, 2009
By mccbre from Palo Alto,CA

"I got this gun for recreational shooting and the gun shoots so smooth that I go out shooting every chance I get I would give this gun a big thumbs up."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 14 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

5 out of 5

Good buy, March 18, 2009
By Tucan733 from SE Wisconsin

"Great Italian reproduction. Mechanics and finish meet full expectations. Dislike extremely large front blade sight. Would like to have same revolver in 36 caliber. Can not beat Cabela's prices."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 15 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

4 out of 5

1858 New Army 5-1/2 inch barrel, March 9, 2009
By kstalcup59 from Edgewood, MD

"This is a fun gun to shoot. The loading lever is shorter than my '58 with 8 inch barrel and my '51 with 7-1/2 inch barrel. It's a little more difficult to ram the lead ball with the shorter loading lever but it's still fun to shoot. I bought this to have a smaller gun for my shoulder holster but it has the same punch as any of my larger guns. I would highly recommend this gun to a friend or to an interested stranger (which I already have done)."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 16 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

5 out of 5

.44 Cap-n-Ball; What a buy!, March 3, 2009
By MOAorbust

"This is my first Pietta BP pistol and I must say that I am impressed. The fit and finish was even better than I expected and it feels great in my hand. I have owned several other BP pistols of various manufacture and I can't say this Pietta version lacks quality in any respect, even though it is by far the least expensive. It loads and fires well with no malfunctions to date. It is very accurate at 25 yds. free handed and I am planning to shoot from a rest and tailor the load soon to see just what this baby can do. You can't go wrong with this one. Looks good, feels great, shoots well...what else could you ask for?!!"

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 17 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

2 out of 5

Its a keeper but needs better nipples to hold cap., February 10, 2009
By Maddtrapper from salisbury , MD

"The pistol is well worth the money. I rate it two because the percusion caps # 10 or 11 will not stay on the nipples. It has a nice blue finish and the grips are average. The trigger pull is sweet.I can hit a phone book at ten yards dead center.If it wasn't for the percusion caps falling off when firing or tilting the pistol . I would rate it a 5.I think cabelas needs to contact the company or provide better nipples with this pistol."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 18 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

4 out of 5

1858 New Army 5 1/2 Barrel .44 Cal. Revolver, February 4, 2009
By Aguilas

"This is my first black powder gun. I'm happy with its performance even though I don't know bullet velocities yet. I like the sound and smoke it produces. I've shot it on two occations. All six bullets left with out fail. I'm using #10 caps and .454 round balls on top of prelubed wads. Accuracy is not bad either. I shot to glass soda pop bottles at 10 yds dead center. I would have given this gun a 5 rating except the blueing is not well done on the triger. Easy to clean and oil. The gun came will good instruction manuel."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 19 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

5 out of 5

excelent, January 10, 2009
By overlooked from oregon

"I got mine for my birthday...naturally I tried to "pick it apart"
as soon as I pulled it out of the box...it's absolutly flawless,
loads well...shoots well...I did bump up the recomended
charg..from 28 grains to 32...and the bullet to a 454...but
I'm still messing with the load...seems to hit pretty well
no mater what I do with it...still using the #11 cap...so
what if I have to squize them to get them to stay on...I don't want to have to pry off the # 10.
anyway...I'm very happy with mine...oh yeah...uncle mikes
sidekick # 3 holster fits it perfectly."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Review 20 for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Overall Rating:

4 out of 5

new army, December 31, 2008
By fatback53 from Colorado Springs, Co

"The revolver looks like it will be fun to shoot. Overall quality was good. One issue with the brass casting for the trigger guard it has some small pin holes on the left side. I look forward to shooting this revolver for many years to come."

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

1-20 of 46

More Reviews for 1858 New Army 5-1/2" Barrel .44 Caliber Revolver

Get Cabela's best sales & specials by e-mail

1-800-237-4444

HACKER SAFE certified sites prevent over 99% of hacker crime.